# TMPA Core S1.0 Stable-Release Audit / 正式版审查

Audit date / 审查日期: **2026-08-10**

## Decision / 裁决

**PASS for S1.0 stable publication. / 通过 S1.0 正式版出版门。**

This decision means the bilingual specification, machine schemas, profiles, Reference Reader, and C01–C14 corpus are internally aligned and reproducible. It is not a product-conformance or independent-validation decision.

本裁决表示中英文规范、机器 Schema、Profile、Reference Reader 与 C01–C14 语料库内部一致且可复跑；它不是产品一致性裁决，也不是独立验证。

## Audit matrix / 审查矩阵

| Area / 领域 | Check / 检查 | Result / 结果 |
|---|---|---|
| Authority / 权威来源 | GitHub document remains the sole normative source; paper and case cannot redefine clauses / GitHub 文档仍是唯一规范来源，论文与案例不得重定义条款 | PASS |
| Bilingual structure / 双语结构 | English and Chinese retain Sections 1–11, Appendices A–B, and C01–C14 / 中英文均保留第 1–11 节、附录 A–B 与 C01–C14 | PASS |
| Terminology / 术语 | object, artifact, view, lifecycle state, business acceptance, three-valued judgment, TMPA → FCoP → CodeFlowMu boundaries remain aligned / 核心术语与三层关系一致 | PASS |
| Schemas | Four Draft 2020-12 schemas compile; embedded object schema is semantically equal to the published artifact / 四份 Schema 可编译，嵌入对象 Schema 与发布工件语义相同 | PASS |
| Lifecycle and authority / 生命周期与权限 | Lifecycle Profile validates; human approval binds type, relation, assignment, role, and independence / 生命周期 Profile 有效；人工批准绑定类型、关系、Assignment、角色与独立性 | PASS |
| Provenance / 来源可追踪性 | Byte-identical deduplication retains all contributing source IDs / 字节相同观测去重后保留全部来源 ID | PASS |
| Determinism / 确定性 | Canonical sorting is Unicode code-point based and permutation-stable / 规范排序采用 Unicode 码点顺序且排列稳定 | PASS |
| Three-valued logic / 三值逻辑 | valid, invalid, undetermined remain the only semantic judgments; view labels remain explanatory / 三个判断值不变，视图标签只作解释 | PASS |
| C01–C14 Reference Reader | 14 PASS, 0 FAIL / 14 项通过、0 项失败 | PASS |
| Product track at release / 正式版产品轨道 | No exact S1.0 product run exists; all 14 criteria remain explicitly NOT RUN / 尚无精确 S1.0 产品运行，十四项继续明确为 NOT RUN | BOUNDED |
| Predecessor product evidence / 前序产品证据 | I0.8 registers CodeFlowMu V1.6.0 against the exact S0.6 bundle with 14 PASS / 0 FAIL on 2026-08-10; it is retained without relabeling / I0.8 登记 CodeFlowMu V1.6.0 针对精确 S0.6 Bundle 的 14 PASS / 0 FAIL，并保持原标识 | PASS |

## Evidence boundary / 证据边界

- **Specified:** S1.0 clauses and schemas.
- **Implemented:** the author-produced S1.0 Reference Reader.
- **Demonstrated:** the Reference Reader's 14/14 fixture run.
- **Predecessor demonstrated evidence:** exact-S0.6 CodeFlowMu V1.6.0 product behavior in the separately locked I0.8 author-run package; not an S1.0 product verdict.
- **Not established:** independent validation or independent adoption.

- **Specified（已规定）：** S1.0 条款与 Schema。
- **Implemented（已实现）：** 作者生成的 S1.0 Reference Reader。
- **Demonstrated（已演示）：** Reference Reader 的 14/14 Fixture 运行。
- **前序已演示证据：** 独立锁定的 I0.8 作者运行证据包记录 CodeFlowMu V1.6.0 针对精确 S0.6 Bundle 的产品行为；不构成 S1.0 产品裁决。
- **尚未建立：** 独立验证或独立采用。

## Promotion conclusion / 升版结论

S1.0 promotes the reviewed S0.6 normative design to the stable publication line and reissues the machine-readable bundle under S1.0 identifiers. The S1.0 Reference Reader passes C01–C14. The predecessor register is retained under `predecessor-evidence/20260810-codeflowmu-v1.6.0/`; it does not establish an exact S1.0 product run, independent validation, or independent adoption.

S1.0 将已审查的 S0.6 规范设计提升到稳定出版线，并以 S1.0 标识重新发布机器可读 Bundle。S1.0 Reference Reader 通过 C01–C14。前序登记保留在 `predecessor-evidence/20260810-codeflowmu-v1.6.0/`；它不建立精确 S1.0 产品运行、独立验证或独立采用。
