{
  "schema": "article-bounded-probe-evidence/v1",
  "date": "2026-11-13",
  "itemId": "SIG-20261113-007",
  "provenance": "Copied from the completed same-date Analysis experiment; Production did not rerun or extend the experiment.",
  "measurementStartedAt": "2026-11-13T05:03:29.051592+00:00",
  "measurementFinishedAt": "2026-11-13T05:03:29.064557+00:00",
  "python": "3.12.9 (tags/v3.12.9:fdb8142, Feb  4 2025, 15:27:58) [MSC v.1942 64 bit (AMD64)]",
  "platform": "Windows-10-10.0.19045-SP0",
  "upstreamExperimentResultSha256": "3c0c9f2a8847296f1ca3111107acc2259c90796f5fd40987fadd3275f2bbda6a",
  "experiment": {
    "id": "EXP-007",
    "kind": "Exact standalone upstream module on synthetic verdicts; not archive reproduction",
    "sourceSha256": "6c1e8233566d803836704855f93cc1b375ce7f76fbddbb623c73528aa032b9f4",
    "cases": [
      {
        "case": "no-link",
        "inputs": {
          "harness": {
            "failed": [
              "H1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "agent": {
            "failed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "links": [],
          "device": null
        },
        "output": {
          "attribution": "agent_caused",
          "label": "agent caused the failure",
          "reason": "no mechanism chain connects any harness defect to any agent-side failure, so the 1 agent failure(s) are charged to the Agent; the 1 harness defect(s) are recorded separately on the harness axis and are not excused",
          "device": {
            "ok": true,
            "measurement_bypassed": false,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "bypass_detail": [],
            "bypass_affected_checks": []
          },
          "harness_layer": {
            "failed": [
              "H1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "agent_layer": {
            "failed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "causal_links": [],
          "notes": []
        },
        "axes": {
          "harness_defect_count": 1,
          "agent_failure_count": 1,
          "traced": 0,
          "untraced": 1
        }
      },
      {
        "case": "empty-chain-''",
        "inputs": {
          "harness": {
            "failed": [
              "H1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "agent": {
            "failed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "harness_criterion": "H1",
              "agent_criterion": "A1",
              "chain": "",
              "confidence": "medium"
            }
          ],
          "device": null
        },
        "output": {
          "attribution": "agent_caused",
          "label": "agent caused the failure",
          "reason": "no mechanism chain connects any harness defect to any agent-side failure, so the 1 agent failure(s) are charged to the Agent; the 1 harness defect(s) are recorded separately on the harness axis and are not excused",
          "device": {
            "ok": true,
            "measurement_bypassed": false,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "bypass_detail": [],
            "bypass_affected_checks": []
          },
          "harness_layer": {
            "failed": [
              "H1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "agent_layer": {
            "failed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "causal_links": [],
          "notes": []
        },
        "axes": {
          "harness_defect_count": 1,
          "agent_failure_count": 1,
          "traced": 0,
          "untraced": 1
        }
      },
      {
        "case": "empty-chain-'   '",
        "inputs": {
          "harness": {
            "failed": [
              "H1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "agent": {
            "failed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "harness_criterion": "H1",
              "agent_criterion": "A1",
              "chain": "   ",
              "confidence": "medium"
            }
          ],
          "device": null
        },
        "output": {
          "attribution": "agent_caused",
          "label": "agent caused the failure",
          "reason": "no mechanism chain connects any harness defect to any agent-side failure, so the 1 agent failure(s) are charged to the Agent; the 1 harness defect(s) are recorded separately on the harness axis and are not excused",
          "device": {
            "ok": true,
            "measurement_bypassed": false,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "bypass_detail": [],
            "bypass_affected_checks": []
          },
          "harness_layer": {
            "failed": [
              "H1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "agent_layer": {
            "failed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "causal_links": [],
          "notes": []
        },
        "axes": {
          "harness_defect_count": 1,
          "agent_failure_count": 1,
          "traced": 0,
          "untraced": 1
        }
      },
      {
        "case": "placeholder",
        "inputs": {
          "harness": {
            "failed": [
              "H1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "agent": {
            "failed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "harness_criterion": "H1",
              "agent_criterion": "A1",
              "chain": "x",
              "confidence": "low"
            }
          ],
          "device": null
        },
        "output": {
          "attribution": "harness_caused",
          "label": "harness caused the failure",
          "reason": "a harness defect is linked to an agent-side failure by an explicit mechanism chain (H1 -> A1)",
          "device": {
            "ok": true,
            "measurement_bypassed": false,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "bypass_detail": [],
            "bypass_affected_checks": []
          },
          "harness_layer": {
            "failed": [
              "H1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "agent_layer": {
            "failed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "causal_links": [
            {
              "harness_criterion": "H1",
              "agent_criterion": "A1",
              "chain": "x",
              "confidence": "low"
            }
          ],
          "notes": []
        },
        "axes": {
          "harness_defect_count": 1,
          "agent_failure_count": 1,
          "traced": 1,
          "untraced": 0
        }
      },
      {
        "case": "nonexistent-harness-endpoint",
        "inputs": {
          "harness": {
            "failed": [
              "H1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "agent": {
            "failed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "harness_criterion": "H999",
              "agent_criterion": "A1",
              "chain": "x",
              "confidence": "medium"
            }
          ],
          "device": null
        },
        "output": {
          "attribution": "harness_caused",
          "label": "harness caused the failure",
          "reason": "a harness defect is linked to an agent-side failure by an explicit mechanism chain (H999 -> A1)",
          "device": {
            "ok": true,
            "measurement_bypassed": false,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "bypass_detail": [],
            "bypass_affected_checks": []
          },
          "harness_layer": {
            "failed": [
              "H1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "agent_layer": {
            "failed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "causal_links": [
            {
              "harness_criterion": "H999",
              "agent_criterion": "A1",
              "chain": "x",
              "confidence": "medium"
            }
          ],
          "notes": []
        },
        "axes": {
          "harness_defect_count": 1,
          "agent_failure_count": 1,
          "traced": 1,
          "untraced": 0
        }
      },
      {
        "case": "nonexistent-both-endpoints",
        "inputs": {
          "harness": {
            "failed": [
              "H1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "agent": {
            "failed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "harness_criterion": "H999",
              "agent_criterion": "A999",
              "chain": "x",
              "confidence": "medium"
            }
          ],
          "device": null
        },
        "output": {
          "attribution": "harness_caused",
          "label": "harness caused the failure",
          "reason": "a harness defect is linked to an agent-side failure by an explicit mechanism chain (H999 -> A999)",
          "device": {
            "ok": true,
            "measurement_bypassed": false,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "bypass_detail": [],
            "bypass_affected_checks": []
          },
          "harness_layer": {
            "failed": [
              "H1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "agent_layer": {
            "failed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "causal_links": [
            {
              "harness_criterion": "H999",
              "agent_criterion": "A999",
              "chain": "x",
              "confidence": "medium"
            }
          ],
          "notes": []
        },
        "axes": {
          "harness_defect_count": 1,
          "agent_failure_count": 1,
          "traced": 0,
          "untraced": 1
        }
      },
      {
        "case": "clean",
        "inputs": {
          "harness": {
            "failed": [],
            "passed": [
              "H1"
            ],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "agent": {
            "failed": [],
            "passed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "links": [],
          "device": null
        },
        "output": {
          "attribution": "clean",
          "label": "clean",
          "reason": "no harness defect and no agent-side failure",
          "device": {
            "ok": true,
            "measurement_bypassed": false,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "bypass_detail": [],
            "bypass_affected_checks": []
          },
          "harness_layer": {
            "failed": [],
            "passed": [
              "H1"
            ],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "agent_layer": {
            "failed": [],
            "passed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "causal_links": [],
          "notes": []
        },
        "axes": {
          "harness_defect_count": 0,
          "agent_failure_count": 0,
          "traced": 0,
          "untraced": 0
        }
      },
      {
        "case": "harness-only",
        "inputs": {
          "harness": {
            "failed": [
              "H1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "agent": {
            "failed": [],
            "passed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "links": [],
          "device": null
        },
        "output": {
          "attribution": "harness_defect_absorbed",
          "label": "harness defective, agent absorbed it",
          "reason": "the harness is defective but the deliverable is sound: the agent absorbed the defect. The defect is real and should be reported; the run is not evidence that the harness broke the task",
          "device": {
            "ok": true,
            "measurement_bypassed": false,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "bypass_detail": [],
            "bypass_affected_checks": []
          },
          "harness_layer": {
            "failed": [
              "H1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "agent_layer": {
            "failed": [],
            "passed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "causal_links": [],
          "notes": []
        },
        "axes": {
          "harness_defect_count": 1,
          "agent_failure_count": 0,
          "traced": 0,
          "untraced": 0
        }
      },
      {
        "case": "agent-only",
        "inputs": {
          "harness": {
            "failed": [],
            "passed": [
              "H1"
            ],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "agent": {
            "failed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "links": [],
          "device": null
        },
        "output": {
          "attribution": "agent_caused",
          "label": "agent caused the failure",
          "reason": "the harness behaved correctly; the deliverable is wrong",
          "device": {
            "ok": true,
            "measurement_bypassed": false,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "bypass_detail": [],
            "bypass_affected_checks": []
          },
          "harness_layer": {
            "failed": [],
            "passed": [
              "H1"
            ],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "agent_layer": {
            "failed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "causal_links": [],
          "notes": []
        },
        "axes": {
          "harness_defect_count": 0,
          "agent_failure_count": 1,
          "traced": 0,
          "untraced": 1
        }
      },
      {
        "case": "apparatus-failed",
        "inputs": {
          "harness": {
            "failed": [
              "H1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "agent": {
            "failed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "harness_criterion": "H1",
              "agent_criterion": "A1",
              "chain": "x",
              "confidence": "medium"
            }
          ],
          "device": {
            "ok": false,
            "measurement_bypassed": false,
            "failed_checks": [
              "trace"
            ],
            "bypass_detail": [],
            "bypass_affected_checks": []
          }
        },
        "output": {
          "attribution": "inconclusive_device",
          "label": "measurement apparatus failed; run is unusable",
          "reason": "the measurement apparatus did not work for this run (trace); no conclusion about harness or agent can be drawn — re-run",
          "device": {
            "ok": false,
            "measurement_bypassed": false,
            "failed_checks": [
              "trace"
            ],
            "bypass_detail": [],
            "bypass_affected_checks": []
          },
          "harness_layer": {
            "failed": [
              "H1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "agent_layer": {
            "failed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "causal_links": [],
          "notes": []
        },
        "axes": {
          "harness_defect_count": 0,
          "agent_failure_count": 0,
          "traced": 0,
          "untraced": 0
        }
      },
      {
        "case": "unmeasured",
        "inputs": {
          "harness": {
            "failed": [],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "agent": {
            "failed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "links": [],
          "device": null
        },
        "output": {
          "attribution": "inconclusive_unmeasured",
          "label": "a required layer could not be measured",
          "reason": "the harness layer produced no measurable criterion in this run; a gap in measurement is not a finding about the subject under test",
          "device": {
            "ok": true,
            "measurement_bypassed": false,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "bypass_detail": [],
            "bypass_affected_checks": []
          },
          "harness_layer": {
            "failed": [],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": false
          },
          "agent_layer": {
            "failed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "causal_links": [],
          "notes": []
        },
        "axes": {
          "harness_defect_count": 0,
          "agent_failure_count": 0,
          "traced": 0,
          "untraced": 0
        }
      },
      {
        "case": "bypass",
        "inputs": {
          "harness": {
            "failed": [
              "H1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "agent": {
            "failed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": []
          },
          "links": [],
          "device": {
            "ok": true,
            "measurement_bypassed": true,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "bypass_detail": [],
            "bypass_affected_checks": [
              "H1"
            ]
          }
        },
        "output": {
          "attribution": "agent_caused",
          "label": "agent caused the failure",
          "reason": "the harness behaved correctly; the deliverable is wrong",
          "device": {
            "ok": true,
            "measurement_bypassed": true,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "bypass_detail": [],
            "bypass_affected_checks": [
              "H1"
            ]
          },
          "harness_layer": {
            "failed": [
              "H1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "agent_layer": {
            "failed": [
              "A1"
            ],
            "passed": [],
            "not_applicable": [],
            "measured": true
          },
          "causal_links": [],
          "notes": [
            "the agent bypassed at least one required measurement channel; under binary scoring the affected Harness criteria score 0, and causal attribution assigns those observation failures to the Agent rather than treating them as intrinsic Harness defects"
          ]
        },
        "axes": {
          "harness_defect_count": 0,
          "agent_failure_count": 1,
          "traced": 0,
          "untraced": 1
        }
      }
    ],
    "finding": "A nonempty placeholder and nonexistent endpoint links can activate harness_caused. Apparatus and unmeasured controls still gate attribution. This is a local module contract observation, not validated causal evidence."
  },
  "boundaries": [
    "Describe EXP-007 as an exact upstream standalone module probe on synthetic verdicts, not a full-system reproduction.",
    "Show empty/whitespace, apparatus-failure and unmeasured controls alongside activating cases.",
    "State no caller audit and no real-run defect/causal-error rate.",
    "Keep 3420-cell counts source-reported and distinguish criterion zeros from confirmed defects.",
    "Retain source-PDF digest mismatch and manifest-name differences as binding uncertainty, not changed-membership evidence.",
    "No first-party implementation recommendation or product-defect priority."
  ]
}
